|
Are you thinking
about trying to cut carbs? The recent resurgence of the Atkins low-carb
diet plan is so enamored by the media/public that a low-carb lifestyle
is now being adopted instead of using it as a diet plan. That kind
of lifestyle can actually make you fatter.
Short-term effects of the Atkins diet do appear to be safe and very
effective. The diet, which has aroused fiery debate ever since its
inception, limits carbohydrates to 20 grams per day during the first
14 days or the "induction phase" and 50 grams during the
"ongoing weight-loss phase". During these phases, unlimited
or liberal amounts of meat, eggs and cheese high in saturated fat
and cholesterol are permitted.
Several of the recent trials and studies show Atkins may well
be a safe and effective weight-loss option for short-term use
- six months up to a year for some people. Please note the key term
used here is "short-term use".
In these trials, it is worthy to note that heart-disease risk factors
improved equally as with a high-carb / low-fat diet (more so for
those participants who were obese participants and inactive). The
Atkins diet also generated greater weight loss at six months, but
the variance in weight loss narrowed and was much the same at 12
months when compared to a high-carb / low-fat diet.
Recent research also suggests the Atkins weight-loss effect has
little to do with "ketosis," which is supposed to begin
once the body uses up the stored carb reserves and is forced to
burn ketones (a byproduct of body-fat breakdown.) The success of
the diet may be attributed to reducing calorie intake by limiting
food choices (strict carb limitations) thus restricting the choices
for overeating. This is the basis of many popular diets like the
cabbage soup diet - after a week, you don't even want to eat, if
all you can have is cabbage soup! The thought of it is almost nauseating.
Like many other weight-loss diet plans, the Atkins diet makes mindless
impulse eating of snack foods like chips, crackers and cookies off-limits.
Every meal you eat demands that you think and plan before you put
it in your mouth.
Claims that the diet reduces blood-sugar swings that result in lowered
appetite have also not been substantiated.
So, what are the effects of long term low-carb dieting? Research
has shown that the improvement in heart-risk indicators for most
people (even while eating all that saturated fat and cholesterol)
is only in effect only as long as you're losing body fat while on
the diet. But, once weight loss ceases, saturated fat and cholesterol
may once again make you at risk. It is because of this that
a long-term low-carb diet high in meat, eggs and cheese may raise
health risks.
Another risk is that low-carb diets simply lack enough healthy nutrient
sources without vegetables, whole grains, fruits, and beans which
have been proven to reduce the risk of heart disease, stroke and
cancer.
The hyped media reports on the Atkins diet has boosted the food
industry's monetary response to profit trends and is quickly turning
what should be a short-term diet plan into a potentially dangerous
and even weight-promoting low-carb lifestyle.
You can now find product after product at your grocery store with
lower carbs and twice the price. Foods naturally lower in carbs
are being re-labeled to take advantage of the phenomena.
That is not the end of the profit bandwagon. Restaurants are taking
their high-calorie and saturated-fat foods and remarketing them
as "low carb" or "Atkins friendly." Major multivitamin
manufacturers have reformulated vitamins that they "claim"
will supply what's missing in your low-carb lifestyle.
To confuse the consumer even further, you will find low-carb food
labeling listing "net carbs". Net carbs are the amount
of carbs that impact blood sugar subtracted from the total carbs.
This net carb-labeling trend encourages consumers to count carbs
instead of calories. (Somewhat reminiscent of just counting fat
grams? I am sure that most of you now realize that eating a bag
of low fat cookies will not help you lose weight!)
Studies have shown that long term weight control is determined by
overall calorie intake, not whether they come from carbs or fat.
Indeed, many new low-carb processed foods have only slightly fewer
calories than their full-carb versions.
Since carbs usually make up the bulk of our calorie intake, you
would have to deduce that to lose weight, you must restrict some
carbohydrate calories. A little common health sense will direct
you to the carb sources that should be restricted like soda, juice
drinks, and other items high in added sugar, as well as white flour
and other refined grain foods (it isn't coincidence that these items
are also higher in calories). You may also want to cut back on some
carbohydrates like potatoes and refined white rice.
Fat calories are best cut from foods high in saturated fat and trans
fat (trans fat is found in partially-hydrogenated oils or vegetable
shortening): fried foods, high-fat dairy foods, fatty meats, butter,
stick margarine, and many types of prepared popcorn, cookies, crackers
and chips.
Other than fatty meats and fatty dairy products, you will see a
pattern to the restricted foods in the last two paragraphs. It is
called "PROCESSED FOODS"! If you want to lose weight,
a good rule of thumb is to stay out of the grocery isles that contain
processed foods. If you do most of your shopping in the fresh produce
and poultry/fish market, you will find weight loss to be much easier
and healthier.
|